The Thinking Partnership's Arabella Ellis was invited to comment in The Financial Times column The Careerist by Rhymer Rigby, which this week considered whether leaders need to be liked.
We're always being told that leaders should be respected
and trusted. But should they be liked too? And, if so, how do you
convince your staff that you're a nice person?
Is being popular good for my
career?
It is not a prerequisite, but it will make your working
life easier. "I'd argue that all good bosses should be trusted and
respected, but some of them go beyond that and are actually liked,"
says social entrepreneur Jo Owen. To be liked, "you need to
genuinely care about people and their careers. People who do this
tend to be rated very highly and inspire great loyalty".
Arabella Ellis at leadership consultancy
The Thinking Partnership,
says: "A big part of
leadership is getting people to go the extra mile and being liked
will help you do that. But it's a bit like being a parent - your
goal should be to create an atmosphere of respect and trust, not to
be everyone's best friend."
How do I stay liked on the
way up?
"In some way it's hardest to be liked in middle
management because your colleagues are also your competitors," says
Mr Owen.
Ceri Roderick of business psychologists Pearn Kandola adds that it
is possible to be competitive without being nasty. "You can
actually get away with being unpleasant to people on your way up,
because you get promoted away from them quite quickly, but sooner
or later it usually comes back to bite you, " he says.
"It's also a reputational thing. If you are unpleasant or
insincere to people, they will tell other people and a bad
reputation is very hard to change."
Mr Roderick says that as you move higher in a company, people
skills become more, not less, important as your results are more
likely to depend on the work of others.
What can I do to connect to
those who work for me?
At higher levels, Mr Owen says, "you need to get
out of the C-suite and talk and listen to ordinary people. It's not
about doing factory inspections with line managers, it's about
conversations with people. It's about having cups of tea. It's not
complicated but it does take courage".
It is also better to spend 10 minutes with one person than it is
to spend 10 seconds with 30 people. Talk - and, just as
importantly, listen - to a few people and they'll tell others about
it. "Once you've spoken to a number of people you leverage the
gossip network. Do it well and your reputation can spread like
wildfire."
Are there any other traits
that help?
Ms Ellis says
humour is a great way of building bridges with staff. "Being able
to laugh - especially at yourself - does a great deal to humanise
you. You should also have a little humility about you too. Don't
believe you're a leader because you're better; acknowledge the role
of chance. Stay grounded - this can be a real challenge as the
higher you get, the less you're criticised. Listen to friends,
spouses and kids - people who won't tell you just what they think
you want to hear."
Are
there any downsides to being liked?
The obvious drawback is that people who
want to be liked too much will be thought weak. "Those who are
naturally too agreeable put relationships ahead of getting things
done," says Mr Roderick. "You have to work on the right level of
agreeableness."
(Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2011)